Tuesday, May 13, 2014

Blog name explained

You might wonder about the title of this blog--a blog I started a loooong time ago, back BC (Before Child). And have neglected. (Neglected the blog, not the child, I hope!)

The full expression is 'fides quaerens intellectum' - Latin for 'faith seeking understanding.' Nowadays, and particularly in the West, we tend to want to understand things before we believe them. (Although Augustine states flatly that this was also the case even in his 5th century North African context, in his Tractates on the Gospel of John 29.6.) Other places and times and cultures may put primary value on trust and relationships, and have (or had) a sense that true understanding came in the context of a relationship of love and trust. Yes, we need to know a bit about a person before we believe them. It helps to know that they are worthy of trust. But truly knowing and understanding them doesn't happen through aloof assessment. You never really get to know someone until you live with them--and even then it is possible to avoid diving deeper and become just swimmers in their own lanes, never crossing the ropes.

This motto comes from Anselm's original title for his philosophical treatise, the Proslogion. He saturated himself in the writing and thought of Augustine, and consciously based his title on a phrase summarizing the life and work of Augustine. Both Augustine (of Hippo, a North African bishop in the early 5th century) and Anselm (medieval philosopher and theologian, and Archbishop of Canterbury from 1093 to 1109) formulated versions of this Latin phrase, summing up their realization that in order to truly understand God and his 'economy' (i.e. God's way of ordering all things and interacting with the world), they had to start from a position of faith, of trust, of connection, of love. Abstract cogitation could only get them so far. Understanding was very important to them. But so was an awareness of putting things in the correct order. For them, the 'seeking' never stopped. The goal of that search was, as Augustine put it, the summum bonum immutabile et commune - the greatest/highest Good which was unchangeable and which could be shared in common with others. In other words, God. The goal was not the perfection of abstraction. Nor was it something in which no one else could participate. The possibility of intimate connection with God had to be accessible to all and shared in the context of community, in worship, in prayer, in praise, in the Eucharist, in life together. Both men were incredible thinkers. But they started from a position of loving trust.

Augustine put it this way: 'credas, ut intelligas' --'You [his audience/congregation/readers] believe, in order that you may understand.' (In Ioannis evangelium tractatus -- i.e., Tractates/Commentary/Homilies on the Gospel of John -- 29.6) Several hundred years later, Anselm rephrased this into the first person: 'credo ut intelligam' -- 'I believe in order that I may understand' (Proslogion 1). Anselm expressed the same idea as fides quaerens intellectum. This is paraphrased by the Anselmian scholar Thomas Williams as “an active love of God seeking a deeper knowledge of God.” (Citation in article below.)

So, whence the URL name? 'Where's Fido?' Fido is an ancient name for a faithful dog, taken from the Latin 'fides'. Fido trusts. He also (once housebroken....) is trustworthy. He will come and find his injured master and drag him to safety. Fido knows that the same master will never let him down. 'Where's Fido?' Where is the one who trusts? Where is faith? How do I begin to have faith, if faith is what I need in order to start out on this journey of seeking understanding. It's a cheeky title, drawn from my love of puns and wordplay (especially wordplay involving more than one language). Fides ... Fido.  Quaerens ... Where are you? I'm looking, I'm seeking? Where can you be found? Fido, where are you? Faith, where can you be found?

Here is a useful section from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (a wonderful free online resource written by pre-eminent scholars in the field) on Anselm's motto, fides quaerens intellectum, in the context of his proofs for the existence of God (the Proslogion and Monologion):

2.1 “Faith Seeking Understanding”: The character and purpose of Anselm's theistic proofs
Anselm's motto is “faith seeking understanding” (fides quaerens intellectum). This motto lends itself to at least two misunderstandings. First, many philosophers have taken it to mean that Anselm hopes to replace faith with understanding. If one takes ‘faith’ to mean roughly ‘belief on the basis of testimony’ and ‘understanding’ to mean ‘belief on the basis of philosophical insight’, one is likely to regard faith as an epistemically substandard position; any self-respecting philosopher would surely want to leave faith behind as quickly as possible. The theistic proofs are then interpreted as the means by which we come to have philosophical insight into things we previously believed solely on testimony. But as argued in Williams 1996 (xiii-xiv), Anselm is not hoping to replace faith with understanding. Faith for Anselm is more a volitional state than an epistemic state: it is love for God and a drive to act as God wills. In fact, Anselm describes the sort of faith that “merely believes what it ought to believe” as “dead” (M 78). (For the abbreviations used in references, see the Bibliography below.) So “faith seeking understanding” means something like “an active love of God seeking a deeper knowledge of God.”

Other philosophers have noted that “faith seeking understanding” begins with “faith,” not with doubt or suspension of belief.  Hence, they argue, the theistic arguments proposed by faith seeking understanding are not really meant to convince unbelievers; they are intended solely for the edification of those who already believe.  This too is a misreading of Anselm's motto. For although the theistic proofs are borne of an active love of God seeking a deeper knowledge of the beloved, the proofs themselves are intended to be convincing even to unbelievers. Thus Anselm opens the Monologion with these words:

If anyone does not know, either because he has not heard or because he does not believe, that there is one nature, supreme among all existing things, who alone is self-sufficient in his eternal happiness, who through his omnipotent goodness grants and brings it about that all other things exist or have any sort of well-being, and a great many other things that we must believe about God or his creation, I think he could at least convince himself of most of these things by reason alone, if he is even moderately intelligent. (M 1)
And in the Proslogion Anselm sets out to convince “the fool,” that is, the person who “has said in his heart, ‘There is no God’ ” (Psalm 14:1; 53:1).

[from http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/anselm/]

So.... there you have it. Faith. Trust. A place to begin.

Re-boot

Is anyone reading these? I will attempt a re-boot of this blog. Leave comments to let me know that you are interested.... (Blogger insecurity here.)

To be honest, I started this blog many years ago for myself. I didn't expect nor really want an audience. I know that sounds odd! I was curious about blogging as a process and technology, and thought it might be useful to learn a bit of HTML. And I saw a usefulness in getting me writing something, anything, to get over certain periods of writer's block while working on my doctorate. But then I had a baby. And the baby had his own blog, for the sake of our far away family and friends. And then the push to finish the thesis. And then Facebook came along... And my writing condensed into short posts on daily life--again largely to keep family and friends up-to-date with our news and our son's latest cuteness (in word and photo).

But now... I see the usefulness of returning to the blog with a fresh purpose: a bit more chewing on ideas and thoughts that inhabit my academic life. To be honest, I find it hard to be a theologian on Facebook. For one thing, there is the all-too-frequent observation that 'Someone on the Internet is wrong!' -- and the temptation to do something about it! This is far too tempting to someone (like myself) whose bread and butter is teaching The Development of Doctrine in the Early Church to A.D. 451 (for Oxford peeps, the Theology and Religion Final Honour School Paper 4). I.e. Heresy 101. I want to stay friends with people and not constantly police their citations of Joel Osteen inter alia. It's not that I won't say on Facebook what I think, if I feel it's necessary. But I'd rather spend more time thinking at more length about topics, and if you do that in a Facebook comment, it just looks . . . rude. And I've done it far too often. I guess I just don't know how to be pithy! The curse of the academic life.

Wednesday, February 09, 2011

To Blog or Not to Blog

Probably no one checks this blog anymore. I nearly forgot it existed myself! Most of my public thoughts are on Facebook or sometimes Twitter these days. But I've noticed that they are indeed brief thoughts. Skimming and skipping over the surface. Blogging may not be much better, but it might be thought of as paragraphs as opposed to 140-character soundbytes. Full-blown essays and chapters and book-length ruminations? A bit beyond that. My mind, however, needs stretching and a bit of calisthenics to get it back into sustained thought. Perhaps blogging again can be a bridge from 'posting' to productivity.

This term I'm teaching via one-on-one tutorials (ah, the Oxford system!) Augustine (circling around the Confessions and topics of theological anthropology, marriage, sexuality--as per the student's request), and Medieval Philosophy. The latter has been a bit of a challenge, as I normally don't have any deep thoughts about much past 500. But... 'medieval philosophy' usually includes a sizeable bit of Augustine (hurray!), and the student was happy to do that. We'll spend the other half of the term on Aquinas, rather than surfing our way through a different philosopher/theologian each week. It's nice having the freedom to go 'off piste' (off trail skiing in the trees, as the locals would call it). Most Oxford tutorials have to follow a pretty strict curriculum based on the B.A. exams they take at the end of three years of undergraduate study. But the two students I have are with an American Junior Year Abroad program, so they have the freedom to study whatever they want--pending approval from their home universities. They are bright and capable, even the ones coming from less prestigious colleges, as they go through a vetting process, and sometimes must be in an honors program to begin with. And it challenges me to get down to academic reading (and gosh maybe writing!) again.

This afternoon I have a seminar on Stoic philosophy and patristic thought, particularly in reference to cosmology, being led by a friend. I have some reading to do for that--and I should be doing reading for my tutorials tomorrow. Or at least remember what I assigned!

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

New Identity

Blogger somehow co-opted my toddler's identity for my posts. It merged accounts somehow, and I couldn't get them unmerged. Hence, the previous couple of posts were by 'JoMo' but were really written by me. Then again, I write MOST of his posts on his blog. Whatever.

I'm back.

Left and Right

Just a little test on whether I'm left or right brain dominant.

Right Brain/ Left Brain Quiz
The higher of these two numbers below indicates which side of your brain has dominance in your life. Realizing your right brain/left brain tendency will help you interact with and to understand others.
Left Brain Dominance: 10(10)
Right Brain Dominance: 9(9)
Right'>http://www.intelliscript.net/test_area/questionnaire/questionnaire.cgi?q=right_brain_left_brain_2">Right Brain/ Left Brain Quiz


Looks like neither half dominates! No wonder I get confused.....

Monday, June 11, 2007

Move on down

Need to add another post or two to move this map down.....

Boy, it seems like I've been to more than 20% of the world's countries, but I'm just not very good on Africa and South America.... and most of Asia, actually.

Now's not a great time to travel, since we have an 18 month old!

Maybe I'll write some more soon, but I'm pretty busy maintaining my son's blog!

I'm baaack!

Not sure for how long, but here is a map of where I've been (approximately... I think I've been to more US states actually).