Friday, May 30, 2014

Sudanese Embassy in Washington, DC, issues a statement on Meriam

...which says precisely nothing. Sudan apparently allows "freedom to choose a religion." What it doesn't say is that if you choose the wrong one, you can be executed. Or put another way, you are free to choose a religion, but there is only one choice available. An "incorrect" choice is invalidated, thus your "freedom" is maintained, but so is the court's freedom to nullify your choice. And if you choose to marry someone in the wrong religion, that marriage is not valid. More Orwellian by the minute.

You can read the statement here.

Friday, May 23, 2014

My form letter reply from the Sudanese Embassy

Yesterday I received a letter in the post (at my Oxford college) from the Embassy of the Republic of the Sudan to the United Kingdom and Ireland, in reply to my letter to the Sudanese Ambassador out of concern for the case of Meriam Yahia Ibrahim, sentenced to 100 lashes and death by hanging for 'adultery' (sleeping with her husband) and 'apostasy' (continuing in the Christian faith in which she was raised). Not at all personalized, apart from the handwritten envelope. You'd think they would figure out if I'm male or female at least. But the fact that I got a form letter reply suggests that they have received a lot of mail on behalf of Meriam. "We can't interfere with our judiciary system"--as if the country were not rife with corruption. "Our country has freedom of religion" -- but apparently not the freedom to change religion nor (if a Muslim, or supposedly Muslim, female) to marry outside your religion (no restrictions if you're male). Nice touch to point out that Sudan was Christian before much of Europe was (and before the arrival of Islam)--but they probably didn't realize they were sending this to a scholar of early church history! "Muslims must believe in Moses and Jesus" -- ignoring the importance of what one believes about them. Still, the letter attempts to be conciliatory, reassuring, and (of course) diplomatic. Moreover, the fact that they bothered to reply suggests that perhaps the government is paying attention to the international outcry. One can hope.


Wednesday, May 21, 2014

Amnesty International - email for Meriam

Amnesty International has made it very easy to send an email--much like the CSW link.

Name, email address, click. And an email goes to government officials in the Sudan.

If you don't wish to send an email via their website, Amnesty International provides the email, fax, and snail mail addresses for several key officials for DIY communication.


Tuesday, May 20, 2014


I've never been caught in this trap. Nope. Not me. Who me??

Friday, May 16, 2014

Twenty seconds

I blogged about Meriam a couple of days ago. Yesterday the court confirmed its sentence, that she would receive 100 lashes for adultery and hang for apostasy. In all likelihood they will wait until her baby is born and weaned before carrying out the sentence, as it is illegal in Islam to execute a pregnant woman. Local sources suggest she is likely to be allowed to live for two years past delivery. Perhaps the executioners are familiar with the WHO (World Health Organization) guidelines that infants be nursed until at least age two, as described here. How...thoughtful and enlightened. 

Meriam's story reminds me very much of that of Perpetua and Felicity, martyred for their faith in Carthage in AD 203. You can see the ruins of ancient Carthage if you visit Tunisia, just a couple of countries up and over from the Sudan, where Meriam and her 20-month-old son are incarcerated. Perpetua was a noblewoman with a young, breastfeeding son (his need to feed and his sudden weaning are part of the narrative that has been preserved--one of the few texts we have from antiquity to discuss these things from a mother's perspective). Felicity was Perpetua's servant girl, a fellow Christian, and quite pregnant. The two faced their judge calmly, refused to recant their faith and make offerings to the cult of the emperor, suffered in prison together with three other fellow Christians, and were condemned to be torn apart by wild beasts in the arena. The judge similarly postponed Felicity's execution until she could deliver her child. She went into labour prematurely and gave birth in the eighth month; she was therefore executed with her friends. 

The text of their fascinating narrative can be found in English translation here. It is a well-known document in my main field (early church history and doctrine, usually called patristics, although here one probably ought to say matristics, or matrology, as we are talking about mothers of the church).

Twenty seconds. That's about how long it took me to fill in a few details to send an email to the Sudanese ambassador to the UK and Ireland. Twenty seconds. Not much longer than it took Meriam to respond to the judge, when he asked her if she had decided to recant her faith and 'revert' to Islam. According to the BBC and other mainstream news outlets, 'Then she calmly told the judge: "I am a Christian and I never committed apostasy."' This echoes the declaration of the Christians before imperial judges in those first centuries: 'Christianus sum' - I am a Christian. The governor of Pontus-Bithynia (in modern day Turkey), Pliny, back in the 2nd century, a couple of generations before Perpetua and Felicity, wrote to the Emperor Trajan to enquire on precisely this point: Could a Christian be convicted merely for confessing 'Christianus sum'? Was that enough, even if they had committed no other crime? Well, that depends, replied the Emperor, but if, after being asked three times, they don't recant, you can go ahead and execute them. (You can read their correspondence, translated from Latin into English, here.) And so with Meriam, who has joined a long line of believers standing up and saying, 'I am a Christian.'

Twenty seconds. You can send an email to the ambassador through this link here.

Wednesday, May 14, 2014

My letter to the Ambassador

Today I did something I always think of doing, but rarely do. I ... did something. Rather than just sit there or post about it on Facebook. I picked up the phone and rang an embassy, in this case the Sudanese Embassy in London. I spoke with a consular officer. And, at his suggestion, I sat down and wrote a letter. Rather than just sitting down.

The case involves a young mother and medical doctor, Meriam Yahia Ibrahim, who has been sentenced to death (ironically on the day when much of the world celebrates Mother's Day) for the crimes of 'apostasy' -- for practicing Christianity her entire life, despite her birth father, who abandoned her Christian mother very early, being a Muslim. Under Sharia law, if the child's father is a Muslim, that child is a Muslim. (Rather like the Jewish law which declares someone Jewish if the mother is Jewish.) Under a similar reckoning, one might argue, as no doubt some extremists have done, that President Obama is "guilty" of apostasy to Islam, as his birth father was a Muslim (albeit an atheist, yet in these legal cases, that does not matter), but that is a very unpleasant line of thought. Further, Mrs Ibrahim has been accused of adultery, for (here is where it gets even more twisted) the crime of sleeping with her husband. The problem is that her husband is also a Christian. As the court has declared her (against her will) a Muslim, she therefore would be bound by Islamic law, which forbids a Muslim woman from marrying a non-Muslim man. Therefore, her marriage is void; therefore, the fact that she has one child and another on the way is evidence that she has slept with a man who is not legally her husband, and thus guilty of adultery. Did you follow that? The word I used to describe this kind of convoluted rationalization that arrives at the opposite conclusion is Orwellian. Good is bad. Freedom is Slavery. Marriage is Adultery.

Here are some articles about Mrs Ibrahim and her life-or-death situation. She has been given just a few days to consider whether she wants to be a Muslim (and if so then just guilty of adultery and due 100 lashes, I imagine, rather than apostasy, which carries the death sentence--although 100 lashes can and frequently is a de facto death sentence). Amnesty International has written here, another article here, from the very reliable CSW, another here, and another update here. This article adds the interesting fact that her South Sudanese husband is also an American citizen (my guess is perhaps he was a refugee during the war?). The Tablet (a venerable UK Catholic publication) has written about it here. So far, not much mention in the mainstream press.

If you would like to do something, feel free to pick up the phone, dial the embassy (from the UK the number is  0207 839 8080 and navigate the menus for the Consular Section. (I think it was 'Press 2.') Feel free to sign an online petition here.

So... here is my letter.


His Excellency Abdullahi H A El Azreg
Ambassador of the Republic of the Sudan
  to United Kingdom and Ireland
Embassy of the Republic of the Sudan
3 Cleveland Row
St. James
London  SW1A 1DD

14 May 2014

Dear Ambassador,

Today I phoned your Embassy in London to register my concern over the case of Mrs Meriam Yahia Ibrahim, a Sudanese woman who was brought on the 4th of March before a Public Order Court in El Haj Yousif Khartoum, and sentenced to death on the 11th of May. I would ask you respectfully to urge your government to release Mrs Ibrahim and absolve her of all charges.

Mrs Ibrahim was raised as a Christian by her Christian mother, and has only ever practised Christianity. Her father abandoned the family not long after her birth and she has no contact with him. However, because her birth father was at least nominally Muslim, she has been declared by the court guilty of apostasy. How can a court be so callous as to punish a child for being abandoned by her father? Should not the guilt, if there is any, fall on him? Further, she has behaved modestly and married, but has been declared guilty of adultery as she chose to marry a fellow Christian. Should not a person have the right to marry within his or her religious community? As an academic teaching theology at the University of Oxford, and as a mother and wife and believer, I find this situation very concerning.

Further, this judgement violates the Constitution of Sudan, which guarantees religious freedom. This court is thus behaving in a capricious way, contrary to the law of the land. “Sudanese Tolerance” is a title of great significance to your country, and it would not seem that this court is acting in the light of that noble heritage and aspiration.

The gentleman in the Consular Section of the Embassy with whom I spoke over the telephone said that he was not familiar with Mrs Ibrahim’s case, and suggested very kindly and helpfully that I write directly to the Consular Section so that the concern may be forwarded to the Sudanese government by them, so I am also sending a copy of this letter directly to that Section. I am grateful for the help he offered. I was a bit surprised that he had not yet heard of this case, as it came to my attention in the UK press. But his lack of awareness only goes to show how this court has clearly passed sentence in the shadows and in a way not fitting to the kindness and respect of the Sudanese people.

Thank you for your time, and I wish you and your country, and Mrs Ibrahim, all the very best.

Yours sincerely,



Dr Susan Griffith

Cc: Consular Section, Embassy of the Republic of the Sudan

Tuesday, May 13, 2014

Rowan Williams on the usefulness of universities

In his typically articulate way, Rowan Williams describes the trend that is spreading throughout the world of academia. And not just academia. My husband spoke last night of how at his work, which is now part of a very large multinational, the push is for EVERYONE to be generating revenue. Yes, everyone can save the company money, and thereby contribute to the bottom line, but how does a bookkeeper generate new revenue, rather than merely ensuring that revenue is not lost through faulty systems and sloppy records? How does a cleaner 'upsell' the clientele? Installing pay toilets? Charging for toilet paper? Many of the positions in a large corporation do not, and indeed ought not (as a potential conflict of interest) be pushed to generate revenue. That's why the corporate metaphor exists: you are part of a body, and not everyone gets to be the hand that takes in the cash. As a classroom teacher, I was not allowed (and rightly so) to become a private tutor to my own students in the subject that I taught them during school hours. I did tutor one student in Greek and Latin etymology in preparation for her taking part in the National Spelling Bee (in which she was a runner up--her brother won a couple of years later, as you can see in a theatrically-released documentary). But I could not have tutored her Latin per se. It would have been a conflict of interest, encouraging me to skimp on my teaching during the day, and rake in the dosh from panicked parents in the evening. (I'm exaggerating slightly....) The university is poorly served if a business model is enforced. There are lessons to be learned from business, but business also has lessons to learn from universities. And businesses clearly are in many cases flunking their exam.

Rowan's article can be found here:
http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/story.aspx?storyCode=2012699